The Four Ms. Bradwells: Review and Giveaway for TLC Book Tours

The natural and proper timidity and delicacy which belongs to the female sex evidently unfits it for many of the occupations of civil life.  The paramount destiny and mission of woman are to fulfill the noble and benign offices of wife and mother.  This is the law of the creator.  ~U.S. Supreme Court Justice Joseph P. Bradley, from his 1873 opinion in Bradwell v. Illinois, denying Myra Bradwell the right to practice law.

These are fighting words to American women of my generation, those of us who came of age in the early to mid 1970’s when bras were being burnt and women were starting to storm the barricades erected around traditional male institutions.  Meg Waite Clayton takes on Justice Bradley’s opinion in her new novel, The Four Ms. Bradwells, about four women who became friends in the early 1970’s during their years in law school at The University of Michigan (Go Blue!)  It’s a story of friendship, of courage, of breaking down barriers in society, in our families, and in our own hearts.

But it’s also a story that’s a bit about one of those “benign offices” which Justice Bradley deemed the “destiny and mission of women” – being a mother.  The women in the book have been profoundly affected by their relationships with their own mothers, and are deeply aware of their responsibilities to instill courage and leadership in their own teenage daughters.

The novel opens in the present day with Professor Elsbieta (“Betts”)  Zhukovski undergoing Senate confirmation hearings for her nomination to become a Justice of the Supreme Court.  Growing up the daughter of a Polish immigrant in Hamtramack, Michigan  (a blue collar suburb of Detroit), Betts has surpassed all the odds and landed in the catbird seat for one of the highest offices in the land.  Her four bosom buddies from college are there to support her: Mia, who traded her law practice for the lens of a camera, working all over the world as a photojournalist; Ginger, who gave up law to stay home and write poetry while raising her children; and Laney, who has has stepped out from years of working behind the scenes in politics and thrown her hat in the ring for a place in the Georgia state legislature.

Initially, Betts’ confirmation seems like a sure thing – until information surfaces about a mysterious death which occurred during the women’s college years, a death that casts a long shadow upon all the “Ms. Bradwells” (a nickname bestowed upon the quartet by one of their  UM law professors).

Very quickly, the novel becomes a mystery story, as well as a lovingly written ensemble piece about what it was like to be a young woman in the 1970’s.  Women were only just beginning to crack the major barriers into a very male dominated society.  And while we had indeed “come a long way, baby,” there was still much work to be done.  As women forayed into positions of increasing power and men looked for ways to hang on to their own authority, sexual harrassment infiltrated the work place, and sexual injustice and discrimination was a major battleground.  While none of these battles have been completely won, great strides have been made in that direction.

Clayton freely admits that the relationship among the Ms. Bradwells is rooted in the strong friendships she herself forged during her years in law school at Michigan.  The book is dedicated in part to “the Women of Division Street,” Clayton’s housemates in Ann Arbor, women whom she continues to count as her closest friends.   At its heart, The Four Ms. Bradwells (like Clayton’s novel The Wednesday Sisters) is about friendship, and about women supporting each other during times of struggle as well as times of triumph.



Thanks to TLC Book Tours, I have a new copy of the book to giveaway to one lucky Bookstack reader!  Leave a comment below about the way a friendship has supported you at some point in your life.  Winner will be chosen at random on April 7, 2011

21 thoughts on “The Four Ms. Bradwells: Review and Giveaway for TLC Book Tours

  1. I can totally relate to this. My closest friends also helped me get through law school – and my parent’s divorce and my own wedding at the same time!

  2. My best friend help me get through my Goldens passing at 15 .Constant phone calls &email just loads of love!!i am a follower.

  3. It was friends sticking by me that helped me through the acute phase of a debilitating illness and who keep me stable even now as I cope with the daily problems of the chronic phase.

  4. I don’t know what I would have done without my friends over this lengthy period of chronic fatigue. I have one friend in particular, who lives in Paris and had been commuting to her university job in the north of England, who also developed chronic fatigue. We’ve bolstered each other up and been able to sympathise completely because our backgrounds and experiences are so similar. She has given up the university in the hope of becoming a professional piano player, and I’ve given up in the hope of becoming a writer. We keep each other motivated, and sane!

    • Sharing the same experiences are what really strengthen the bonds of friendship. The Four Ms. Bradwells makes that very clear!
      I’m glad you have such a friend 🙂

  5. As someone who moves around so frequently, I’m incredibly grateful for the constant of long-term friendship and it’s presence via telephone and email. There are some days when emails from my best friends from high school get me through the days. This book just sounds wonderful to me. I adore narratives told from multiple points of view, and I’m incredibly intrigued by the Supreme Court element too.

  6. My best friends are like family to me. When my first baby was born, two of them showed up to celebrate and help out for a week. We unite for weddings and babies whenever we can.

  7. She does write about friendship very well..I enjoy reading these kinds of ensemble novels, too 🙂

    Thanks for the award, Laurel~ off I go to check it out!

  8. This sounds like a compelling story, what with the feminist issues and the theme of friendship, and then the mystery aspect as well. I’m glad to see it was a good read. Thanks for being on the tour!

  9. Thanks for the giveaway, please enter me. WordPress has changed you blog format for IPad users, can you disable it so it does not get changed. Thanks!

  10. I never would have gotten through my two bouts of postpartum depression with the support of my friends. They let me sit in their kitchens while they tended my children, made sure that I, and my kids, were always safe, listen, didn’t listen – just sat with me which is just as important, and many other things.

  11. My best friend has helped me through some major life changes. Marriage, family, and moving all over the country. I couldn’t do any of it without her.

  12. Pingback: Meg Waite Clayton, author of The Four Ms. Bradwells, on tour March/April 2011 | TLC Book Tours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s